Sunday, April 19, 2020

Re–starting Cities : some suggestions to India’s Major Municipal Corporations

April  16,  2020


Dear Municipal Commissioner

Namaste !

In the next 18 days (at most another week)  it is likely that the lockdown imposed,  because of the COVID19,  will be lifted and life will have to be nursed back to normalcy.

Our large cities are going to face a huge logistical challenge when this lockdown comes - perhaps bigger than the challenges faced in imposing and maintaining this lockdown !

Bearing in mind that there will be an unbearably high level of demand for municipal services to get back to  pre-lockdown levels,  and the fact that monsoon is soon expected,  just 6 to 8 weeks away,  I have formulated a list of possible steps you can take now itself to prepare yourself for the demands that will be  placed on you and your staff,  post  May 3, 2002.

The same is enumerated below.  I hope you will find the suggestions helpful in this task.

You have all been doing a very difficult and heroic task since March 25, 2020  and I wish you all a high level of energy, personal safety and good health in the even more monumental task that lies ahead.


hemendra k. varma
A Concerned Citizen


Re–starting Cities : some suggestions to India’s Major Municipal Corporations

Sl No

Proposed  Action  Plan

Remarks

 Reasons / Benefits
1
Immediately launch a drainage cleaning drive, particularly in the water-logging prone areas,  to avoid flooding during the monsoons which is just  8 weeks away.
In view of the lockdown & short time available now,  forego the quotation/ tender process and simply award the work to 2 or 3 contractors on last year’s rates.  Pass a special resolution or ordnance for this purpose.
With the lockdown in force,  this work can be carried out speedily without any disturbance from traffic & people on the road.

At this time,  it will also give employment (and, hence, money) to hundreds and thousands of daily wage-earners,  which is the need of the hour.

2
Immediately  implement a 15 % cut in water supply for April,  15 % in May and 20 % in June to be reviewed and re-adjusted at the end of June depending on Monsoon performance.
This will give a saving of approx. 2 days water in April and 4.5 and 6 days in June giving a buffer of approx. 12 days water supply should monsoon play truant.
We are already suffering from the CORONA Virus ; imagine how much more difficult life will become if people have to face a water shortage, should Monsoons get delayed this year ?

Hence this cut is suggested as an ADVANCE  measure of abundant caution.
Please avoid temptation to become popular by NOT making a water cut – remember people will eventually hail you for your caution even though,  temporarily,  they may criticize you.

3
Utilize these 18 days (or more)  to work on a war footing to tend to all known and visible pot-holes to avoid the inevitable car accidents and vehicle damage that takes place during monsoons
It will be much easier to do it now owing to completely “traffic-free”  road availability.
However, the key is to start the work immediately for which, once again Municipalities will have to  forego the quotation/ tender process and simply award the work to 2 or 3 contractors on last year’s rates.  Pass a special resolution or ordnance for this purpose.

This will not only make driving easier but also save lives as so many accidents, particularly of 2 and 3-wheelers happen when they speed over “unseen potholes” during monsoons.

Also there will never be such an ideal situation to carry out these works because of the free roads these days.
4
Use this time to clean –up, disinfect and sanitise all place of tourist interest in the city,  particularly through soap–wash of all statues and monuments, which always tend to get ignored.

the key is to start the work immediately for which, once again Municipalities will have to  forego the quotation/ tender process and simply award the work to 2 or 3 contractors on last year’s rates.  Pass a special resolution or ordnance for this purpose.
When we emerge form this COVDI19 Lockdown,people will not only be able to heave a sigh of relief bt get a much cleaner and aesthetically beautiful city which will work like an antidote for uplifting the grim mood that people are living in, these days.
5
Institute a rule, that all Street Hawkers  selling  Food / Snacks  must use ONLY  Stainless Steel Containers or Cooking Vessels except for TAWA.

A generous time of 12 months to implement this directive can be given to all such hawkers.
Stainless steel vessels and utensils are much easier to clean ; as  a result a reasonable scrub-wash removes all old food which otherwise tends to cling to other kinds of containers and is a home for bacteria, worms and eventual disease.
With the much heightened  awareness about the importance of personal hygiene and food cleanliness because of the CORONA Virus,  people will be much more open to implementation of this measure today than ever before.

Of course this will raise their cost of operation and,  hence, their prices but this is a necessary COST that we have to bear to save future generations from  diseases caused by poor hygiene.

In the long run, business will only increase as people get confidence about their cleanliness ; they will also get increasing patronage from foreign tourists who otherwise do NOT eat at such Street outlets.

6
Street Hawkers and all Sweet (Mithai)  Shop Staff must wear Head Covering and gloves ; to be implemented within 3 months of such declaration.
Regular inspection by Municipal Staff with on-the-spot fines to be levied for violation plus “Violation-photograph” and sticker put mentioning Violation 1, 2, 3 etc.  On 4th violation shop to be shut for 1 week

Will drastically improve Hygiene and significantly bring down infection / stomach ailments caused by eating street food.
Will upgrade the city’s food outlets to international standards.
7
Hawkers must only serve in disposable plates – Leaves, Mud/Clay, paper or Recyclable Plastic ; to be implemented within 3 months of such declaration.
Regular inspection by Municipal Staff with on-the-spot fines to be levied for violation plus “Violation-photograph” and sticker put mentioning Violation 1, 2, 3 etc.  On 4th violation shop to be shut for 1 week
Today, re-usable plates are washed in the same dirty water kept in a large bowl or bucket and used for re-serving to the next customer – it is a horribly unhealthy and unhygienic system
This measure will help to avoid the above and will upgrade the city’s food outlets to international standards.

8
Hawkers must keep only Filtered water Jars with them which will be checked every 3rd day plus 1 random check every week to ensure that is it indeed filtered. This should  be implemented within 3 months of such declaration.
This is not difficult to implement but certainly involves a cost which the hawker and/or the customer has to bear for his own health safety.
Municipality has to ensure that “it is really filtered water that is being used” by making regular and frequent sample checks with heavy on-the-spot fines for violations.
The supply of this filtered water can be arranged from IRCTC which sells at a much cheaper rate than private bottlers and a special rate for hawkers can be worked out with IRCTC which will be getting a huge volume of business. 

Water-borne disease are the single largest cause of all stomach ailments and this move will,  therefore,  greatly eliminate the same which will lead to tremendous savings in medical cist, though the same will accrue to different segments of society and not to the hawker.
However, in view of Proposal No 5, above,  eliminating the use of re-usable plates,  the “water-requirement”  of the vendor itself will do down substantially and hence the cost increase for them may not be huge.
9
Municipality must provide adequate numbers of large waste segregation Bins (Food waste, Paper & Plastic, All other categories)  in all Food Court and Food Vending Areas.
The bins being used today by different vendors are extremely filthy, of varying sizes and in varying states of collapse !

Municipality should provide a standard, colour coded bins and incur the capital cost for the same.
One of the major reasons for garbage on the streets and footpaths in our city is the woeful lack of garbage bins at reasonable distance. 
Each Metro must aim for ONE set of 3 Garbage Bins (Floor, Paper/Plastic & Others) at every 100 Metre length of Road  and Multiple sets at Food Courts / Food vending areas / Parks etc.,  depending on volume of people-traffic in that area.
Provision of the garbage bags will give authorities the moral right to enforce “No littering  Fines”  as to day people rightly protest – “where should I throw the garbage if not on the street ?”

10
Cleaning (Physical sweeping, wet wiping and white-wash) and thorough disinfection of Municipal Schools.
This can also be mandated for all Private Schools who should be asked to self-certify that they have done this and, then random checks carried out on at least 30 % of such schools.

This is highly important in view of the COVID19 outbreak and will give parents a sense of confidence in sending their children to Municipal Schools
Will ensure a minimum level of cleanliness and hygiene in the schools which can become the new benchmark that schools need to adhere to and maintain.
11
Thorough cleaning of Municipal School Toilets and replacement of broke damaged accessories where necessary
Use COvid19 donation funds for this as it is essential to fight COVID19 when children come back for school. 
Ask Corporates who are  manufacturing Toilet Accessories to donate their products as part of their support to fighting COVID19.

This is one of the major reasons why parents DO NOT send their children to Municipal Schools, especially those with girl-child ; having  clean and hygienic toilet facilities will significantly reduce this barrier
12
Clearing of all Routine and Standard Requests for various permissions
This will save you a huge crowd of citizens coming to your offices whenever they open asking “what happened to my request ?”

This will be welcomed by citizens and many of these can be done digitally, by e-mail etc. for which a limited number of staff can be called in for work immediately.
13
Issuance of Reminders of Non – payment of Municipal Taxes by Housing Societies and Individuals
Will put the onus on the citizen/society to make their payments and give them time to organize for the same.

Many of these can be done digitally, by e-mail etc. for which a limited number of staff can be called in for work immediately.
14
Clearance of papers on desk
Do it NOT by writing a Note and forwarding it to the next Officer but do it in Joint meetings every day, where all departments are present and clarifications given there and then and appropriate decision taken jointly.

This new way of working will develop a healthy sense of camaraderie and team-work and, over a period of time,  can become the norm which will greatly speed-up  paper-work disposal.



We will be happy to provide you any clarification or any assistance you may need for fleshing out the details of the above proposals.



(Hemendra K. Varma)      

16  April  2020

No comments: